My letter to the Editor was published in the Collegian today. By 11:30am I had already recieved one hate email from a lady and one e-mail from a member of our Armed Services. I just checked my email again and there is another hate email.
I will start by saying this; The Daily Collegian did not print my whole article. They left out some of the more infuriating details that I had really hoped they wouldn't. My article printed in the collegian is
located here. My original was this:
I have never in my time here at State College read a more infuriating article printed in the Collegian. Ben Praster seems to have everything figured out but in reality he understands nothing about the culture or religion of the Middle East. The Middle East is not interested in "talking" or "sharing" with the West. As more and more countries fall victim to Muslim tyranny, more and more options for peace are wiped away. To even suggest that sending our students to the Middle East to study abroad is absurd. The Islamic theocracies of Afghanistan, Iran etc. are not interested in expanding their "culture" unless it involves killing Americans or anyone else who isn't interested in becoming a Muslim. Praster's idea of dropping "piles of cash" for "indepentdent radio stations or newspapers" or "international schools" lacks any rational thought. He is suggesting that we spend money to fund independent radio stations in vicious theocracies that would surely use them to push the ever famous Muslim agenda of "kill all infidels". Mohammad said it best, "I was ordered to fight the people until they believe in Allah and His Messenger." The Muslim nations must ask themselves what can they do for humankind, before they demand that humankind respect them. This sort of diplomacy that Ben Praster is suggesting is the same hippie thought that would have had us stand back and fund radio stations and semester abroads for Nazi Germany whilst Hitler raped the land and killed off the entire Jewish population. Surprisingly enough, Praster says we should save the money we are going to inevitably spend fighting a war in Iran to fund these diplomatic projects. That's funny to me, especially since the President of Iran is intent on killing all the Jews in Jerusalem. But, sure, let's just send him some money for a radio station so he has something to occupy his time, instead of genocide through nuclear armament. http://DoctorAwkward.blogspot.comI have bolded and enlarged the portion they left out so that the two people, which I will respond to shortly, can read what they had missed.
Ok, on to the first email, written by
Kathy Heel was full of great information that an idiot like me couldn't possibly understand. I will do with this as I have done before and "disect" her email so that I may address everything appropriately.
First:
Jon,
You must be the biggest brainwashed,narrow-minded idiot in penn State.period.
Here is why:
Ben Praster seems to have everything figured out, but in reality he actually understands nothing about the Middle East.
oh well.jon you must be an expert in Middle East then.
The Middle East is not interested in "talking" or "sharing" with the West. As more countries fall victim to Islamic tyranny, more options for peace are wiped away. To suggest sending our students to the Middle East to study abroad is absurd. The Islamic theocracies of Afghanistan, Iran and various other countries are not interested in expanding their "culture" unless it involves killing Americans or anyone else who isn't interested in becoming a Muslim. Praster's idea of dropping "piles of cash" for "independent radio stations or newspapers" lacks any rational thought.
Here are some facts Jon.
in 1953,CIA overthrown a democratically elected President of Iran because he refused to give up his oil to British Petroleum.
read here: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mohammed_Mossadegh
we removed their democratically elected leader and installed a puppet leader and we blamed them when they were mad with us??I'll set aside the insults because frankly I could care less what this lady has to say about me. Especially since she can barely write. Anyways. Kathy wrote about Mossadegh, but it goes a little deeper than her small anti-American propaganda speech. The Coup of Mohammed Mossadegh in 1953 had everything to do with something called the
Abadan Crisis, which lasted from 1951 to 1954. Basically, Mossadegh initiated a group called the
National Front of Iran to expell all foreign intrests who owned and operated oil refineries and wells in Iran, which at the time was basically one company which ruled them all, Anglo-Iranian Oil Company(AIOC). The previous Prime minister General Haji-Ali Razmara, who was elected in June 1950, right before Mossadegh, had opposed the Oil Nationalisation Act on grounds of technicality (being that the company was owned by the British, the Iranians couldn't just out them).
He was assassinated on March 7 1951 by a member of the Fadayan-e Islam after a group of Muslim clerics issued a fatwa calling for his death. On April 28 1951, Mossadegh was elected BY THE IRANIAN PARLIMENT with a vote of 79-12. Mossadegh, shortly after being voted in, passed the Oil Nationalization Act, which involved the expropriation of the AIOC's assets (an illegal act in world business). The Abadan Crisis ensued and Mossadegh was ousted. I think you see my point here folks, or at least I hope you do. We are NOT working with a government in Iran, we are working with a network of terrorist Muslim Clerics who decide EVERYTHING about their country's future, a Muslim Theocracy. I suppose, Kathy, that maybe you should read into these links that you send to me before you spit your Liberal rhetoric at me.
Second:
Islamic theocracies involved killing the Americans ugh? well,let see....http://www.guardian.co.uk/g2/story/0,,1741699,00.htmlFrom the article:He claims that US soldiers such as him were told little about Iraq, Iraqis or Islam before serving there; other than a book of Arabic phrases, "the message was always: 'Islam is evil' and 'They hate us.' Most of the guys I was with believed it."Blake says that the turning point for him came one day when his unit spent eight hours guarding a group of Iraqi women and children whose men were being questioned. He recalls: "The men were taken away and the women were screaming and crying, and I just remember thinking: this was exactly what Saddam used to do - and now we're doing it."sound familiar Jon?how brainwashed our soldiers are,just like you.What I find intriguing about what the Soldier mentioned and quoted in this article is that he gives us no insight as to WHY those men were being questioned. It is articles like that, Kathy, that spread more and more anti-American propaganda. Black claims that we are not seeing the "real" war. The media is covering ONLY THE BAD things that happen in Iraq. I have talked to countless Soldiers who have returned who have nothing but good things to say about what we are doing. Young Iraqi children hugging them, women thanking them. But you will never hear about that on the news. It is always the negative that you will hear. Our Soldiers aren't brainwashed, Kathy, they are the ones over there every fucking day getting killed and protecting your right to despise them and spread more of your garbage about them. THEY protect YOU, remember that. And another thing; we don't need to kill Iraqis, they're not the ones killing us.
But they are the ones killing themselves. They are killing their own people indiscriminantly. The attack today in Baghdad was not intended for any American Occupiers, they were targeting and killing their own people. THEY ARE KILLING THEIR OWN PEOPLE!!!!!!!!!!!!
Third:
Here is the worse:Yahoo ArticleGriffin said he believed US soldiers had no respect for Iraqis, whom they regarded as "sub-human"."You could almost split the Americans into two groups: ones who were complete crusaders, intent on killing Iraqis, and the others who were in Iraq because the army was going to pay their college fees," he said."They had no understanding or interest in the Arab culture. The Americans would talk to the Iraqis as if they were stupid and these weren't isolated cases, this was from the top down."There might be one or two enlightened officers who understood the situation a bit better but on the whole that was their general attitude. Their attitude fuelled the insurgency. I think the Iraqis detested them."Again, Kathy, propaganda. This British soldier talks about how Americans were "rounding" up "innocent" Iraqis to question them, old men and farmers too. You, and many people like you, don't seem to understand the type of enemy we are fighting. They are faceless. They are the 10 year old walking down the street or the old man sitting at the bus station. I REFUSE to be your teacher on the Insurgence but I
IMPLORE you to
watch this program on PBS:Frontline. It is called
The Insurgency. Maybe that will be the spittle and dirt that rubs your eyes and gives you sight.
Fourth:
Oh Jon...killing the Jews in Jerusalem?There are more Arabs in Jerusalem you know.What about the Jews who can't wait to expel the Arabs from Israel..or Israeli youths who can't wait to kill the Arabs:Just last week I visited a well-known high school in Jerusalem. A good many of the students I spoke to told me appalling things. They said: When we are soldiers, we will kill old people, women and children without giving it a thought. They said: We will expel them, we willput them on planes and fly them to Iraq. We will fly hundreds of thousands of them. Millions. And most of the students in the audience applauded those opinions. They supported them even when I pointed out that that is how people talked 60 years ago in Europe. -- Avrum Burg, former Speaker of the Knesset: On The Eve Of Destruction68% of racist Jews refused to live next door to the Arabs:http://www.ynetnews.com/articles/0,7340,L-3231048,00.htmlI AM SICK READING YOUR LETTER. please jon,go and pick some books.You again don't amaze me. What does the fact that there are more Arabs in Jerusalem than Jews have ANYTHING TO DO WITH WHAT I SAID??? Do you even know? You talk about the Jewish children who want to expel the Arabs from Jerusalem without a brain in your head, Kathy. You don't seem to understand that these
CHILDREN have grown up and witnessed absolutely NOTHING but Muslim acts of terrorism in their own backyards. And the same goes for the Palestinian children who hold the exact same feelings about the Jews as they do for them. You can't just throw a quote out in the air and expect everyone to be in a trance because of it. You must dig deeper and understand the history of the Middle East. You clearly don't. Thanks for writing me, I've enjoyed this, however infuriating it may have been.
The next email is from
Jared Bendes, and it goes a little something like this:
Dude,WTF is wrong with you?No letter made me so mad than your letter.If I was not inside the bus when I was reading it,I would be tearing it apart.dude,get a life.get out and learn something.My friends are in American University of Cairo and they are having bricks of fun.The Muslims treat them with great respect.Nobody wants to kill them becoz they hail from USA as you stupidly wrote.
When we are killing the infidels,the non-Christians,the non-westerners in Iraq...you ignored that with memes like freedom and democracy.saving the Muslims from the "salvages" gave us right to have preemptive strike,ugh.btw idiot,Afghanistan is not a Middle east nation.get an Atlas.Btw your previous letter to the Collegian was showing your holier than thou attitude:http://www.collegian.psu.edu/archive/2005/12/12-09-05tdc/12-09-05dops-letter-04.aspThe heroes of WWII are remembered except we don't go and say to others with a condescending voice " shame on you for not remembering them".get a life.Your friends that attend the American University in CAIRO aren't exactly at the center of Islamic Jihad, Jared. You seem to have misunderstood everything that I have said. The Islamic Theocracies of the Middle East want nothing but Islam in their countries, anything else is punishable by death, as was the fucking case with
Abdul Rahman, who was to be put to death because he converted from Islam to Christianity in a "democratic" country. His next paragraph is illegible, so I am not even going to try and write anything about it. He then turns to calling me an idiot because he thinks I don't know where Afghanistan is. I, uh, I'm still not really sure what the hell to say to that third grade bullshit. And lastly he attacks my previous article about Pearl Harbor. He must not have read that article either. We do NOT remember our WWII heroes when we blatantly disregard the anniversity of Pearl Harbor. Shame on you Jared for your lack of reading comprehension, shame on you.
Lastly, I will post in its entirety the email I got from Daniel Dougherty, a brave Soldier fighting for us ALL in the Middle East.
Thanks for your email Dan, and thank you even more for defending our freedom!
Jon-My name is Dan Dougherty and I am a former PSU student now serving in the military over in the Middle East. During downtimes I tend to read the collegian online and usually get a laugh when I open up the opinions page. For some reason many of the students think just because they are in college, they have a creative writing style, and a first amendment right that what they are really saying is intelligent. It baffles me that people sometimes have such strong convictions about issues they don’t have a darn clue about. Sure, they probably read up on cnn.com and maybe some message boards but the fact is that they really think they are making valid points. What they need to understand is that its an “opinion” page and to stop acting like its some political revolution they are starting by writing about some topic.Why I was writing….I RARELY see intelligent comments on that page and just wanted to tell you I thoroughly enjoyed what you had to say. While I was at PSU people had this vision that there is going to be peace on earth, and that every single nation will respect one another. That we will do anything we can by learning about other cultures in an after school club or semester overseas and magically become the Dali Lama. That’s why I had to get out of the college environment. I wanted to experience the world with my own eyes. I get to sit down with Muslims of all the middle Eastern countries on my days off and just shoot the shit about life and other general stuff. People are people. Doesn’t matter where you go. Some of these people don’t see their families for 3-5 years and make $200 a month just to put food on their tables. AND they’re happy! Some others have children in US colleges for them to learn business and take over their jewelry businesses over here. I might be rambling but I was just trying to say that human being are all the same but where they are from makes a huge difference. These American kids don’t understand that countries over where I am have been with their ways of life for hundreds of thousands of years and they really don’t give a shit to have Americans infiltrate their country and try to be peace makers and save the world. The best bet is just respect other countries ways of life if they don’t appreciate outsiders. If you want to learn so much about these countries pick up a book. Theres plenty other places in the world to visit. Of course you don’t have to respect radicalism from certain groups but just the strict lifestyles that protect their history. Their history that feels like it could be damaged by others bringing their cultures and beliefs inside their borders. Let sleeping dogs lye.I really rambled and was jumping the gun on what I just wrote so take it all with a grain of salt. I was just responding merely on emotion from being upset about certain people. I hope you are enjoying your time in Happy Valley and I look forward to your next post!DanThanks again Dan for serving us All!
Comment it up!!